Metro
Man Who Donated His Kidney To His Wife Demands It Back During Divorce
A New York surgeon, Dr. Richard Batista, made global headlines after demanding that his estranged wife return the kidney he had donated to her—or pay him $1.5 million in compensation—during their divorce proceedings.
Dr. Batista, a respected surgeon from Long Island, had donated one of his kidneys to his wife, Dawnell Batista, in 2001 when she was battling end-stage kidney failure. At the time, the gesture was widely seen as an extraordinary act of love and devotion.
However, just four years after the life-saving transplant, the couple’s marriage deteriorated, and Dawnell filed for divorce. The move reportedly shocked Batista, who later demanded either the return of his organ or financial compensation for what he described as a “gift of love” that had been betrayed.
“I saved her life, and then she turns around and files for divorce,” Batista was quoted as saying during a media interview at the time. “I wanted the organ back because it was a symbol of my commitment. If that’s not possible, I want fair compensation.”
The case quickly sparked a storm of debate in medical and legal circles. Could a donated organ be reclaimed after a breakup? Did such a gesture have monetary value in the eyes of the law?
Legal and medical experts were swift to condemn the demand, describing it as both legally impossible and ethically unsound. According to U.S. law, once an organ is donated, it is considered an irrevocable gift and can never be treated as property or used as leverage in financial disputes.
In 2009, the New York State Supreme Court formally ruled against Batista’s claim, citing the National Organ Transplant Act of 1984, which prohibits the buying or selling of human organs for any reason. The court further clarified that a kidney donation, even within a marriage, carries no financial or marital ownership rights once it is transplanted.
Justice Jeffrey Grob, who presided over the case, emphasised that organ donation is a medical act based on consent and altruism—not a contractual exchange. “There is no monetary value assigned to human organs under the law,” he said in his ruling.
Though Batista’s emotional plea was rejected, the case reignited public discussion about love, sacrifice, and resentment within intimate relationships. Many saw it as a cautionary tale about mixing medical altruism with marital expectations, while others sympathised with Batista’s sense of betrayal after such a profound personal sacrifice.
Ethicists noted that while organ donation between spouses is not uncommon, it can create deep emotional ties that may later complicate divorce or separation. “When something as personal as an organ becomes part of the relationship, the boundaries between love and obligation can blur,” said one medical ethicist.
Dr. Batista’s story remains one of the most talked-about intersections of love, medicine, and law. It serves as a reminder that some gifts—especially those given from the body—can never be taken back, no matter how relationships change.
The Enugu State Police Command has announced the arraignment and remand of 51-year-old Emeka Emmanuel Nwangwu, a member of a Neighbourhood Security Watch group, for the alleged murder of his 19-year-old cousin, Loveth Uloma Nwangwu.
The development followed the conclusion of investigations by the State Criminal Investigation Department (State CID).
The Command’s Public Relations Officer, SP Daniel Ndukwe, confirmed the development in a statement issued on December 10, 2025, noting that the action was in line with the directive of the Commissioner of Police, CP Mamman Bitrus Giwa, psc, who had ordered a thorough investigation and immediate prosecution.
According to the police, the suspect was arrested on December 1, 2025, in Nsukka after he allegedly assaulted the victim, inflicting serious injuries that resulted in her death.
“Upon his arrest, the Commissioner of Police directed the State CID to conduct a meticulous investigation and ensure that the case was promptly charged to court,” Ndukwe stated.
Following the completion of investigations, the suspect was brought before the Enugu State Magistrate Court on a one-count charge of murder. The court thereafter ordered his remand and instructed that the case file be forwarded to the Ministry of Justice through the Directorate of Public Prosecution (DPP) for review and legal advice.
Commissioner Giwa extended his sympathies to the bereaved family, assuring them that justice was firmly underway.
“I express my heartfelt condolences to the family and friends of the deceased,” he said. “They should take solace in the fact that justice is already in motion, as the investigation has been concluded and the suspect has been arraigned and remanded accordingly.”
The Police Command reiterated its commitment to ensuring that the legal process is diligently pursued as the case progresses.
Suspected bandits, weekend, kidnapped two Chinese nationals at Bode Saadu axis of Moro Local Government area of Kwara State.
The incident happened when the bandits were supervising the BUA Bode Saadu/Kaiama/Kosubosu multi billion naira road.
It was gathered that, the bandits were said to have stormed the road and shot sporadically before they were finally kidnapped.
Sources close to the people of Ejidongari area where the Chinese nationals were working before the bandits attacked were shocked following the sporadic shooting that pervaded the area.
Sources said, the bandits were said to have taken the two Chinese nationals into the forest.
The bandits were yet to demand any ransom as at the time of filling this report last night.
The state police commissioner, Mr. Adekimi Ojo, who confirmed the incident said, the men of the state police command had been working round the clock to ensure the rescue of the two Chinese nationals.
He, therefore, urged members of the public to continue to support the police in its task of curtailing the activities of the bandits in the state.
A 33-year-old married female Mathematics teacher has been arrested in Zimbabwe after a graphic sex video she recorded with her 16-year-old Form 4 student went viral on WhatsApp and TikTok.
The teacher, whose identity is being withheld to protect the minor, allegedly invited the boy to her home for “private lessons” to help him improve his grades. According to the boy’s statement to police and child protection officers:
“I was failing Mathematics.
She promised she could make me understand everything quickly if I came for extra tuition at her house after school.
The first day I went, she locked the door, started touching me, removed my clothes, and forced herself on me. This happened several times.
She was the one recording the videos.”
The boy says the teacher threatened to fail him and tell his parents he was “stubborn” if he refused or told anyone.
The explicit footage, lasting over 8 minutes, shows the fully naked teacher on top of the minor while filming with her phone. It spread like wildfire after the boy confided in a friend who leaked it.
The teacher was arrested yesterday (December 5) and is detained at Harare Central Police Station.
She faces charges of statutory rape, sexual exploitation of a minor, and producing child pornography under Zimbabwe’s Criminal Law Act.
The Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education has suspended her with immediate effect and launched an internal investigation.
The boy has been placed under psychological counselling.
Child rights organisations have commended the student for speaking out, saying many male victims suffer in silence due to stigma.
This case has reignited national outrage over teacher-on-student sexual abuse, with demands for mandatory background checks and CCTV in tuition centres.
Justice must not only be done; it must be seen to be done.
No child should ever have to trade their body for grades.
Finally, Trump unveils $1m gold card for the super rich
Benin Republic confirms coup leader, Tigri is hiding in Togo
SAD: Trailer Collides With Bus, K!lls 8 UNIJOS students
Edo Killings: Jibrin Shares Details of His Discussion with Okpebholo
Jail break: One of Seven Escaped Ilesha Inmates re-arrested in Lagos
Police neutralise bandit, rescue 5 kidnapped victims in Katsina
-
News23 hours agoOsun First Lady sends message laced with humility to Remi Tinubu after public rebuke of husband
-
News22 hours agoReps In Rowdy Session, Summons CBN Governor Cardoso Over Non Remittance of N16trn
-
News22 hours agoBill To Strengthen Nigeria’s Statistical Data Pass Second Reading
-
News12 hours agoEx-Governor Chris Ngige Arrested
-
Economy11 hours agoFG pushes for N17.89tn new loans to finance 2026 budget
-
News21 hours ago
Osun guber: Tinubu meets APC guber aspirants in Aso Villa
-
News22 hours agoECOWAS Ministers Open Abuja Meeting with Strong Demands for Stability, Democracy, and Deeper Integration
-
News4 hours agoOyebamiji set to be crowned Osun APC consensus candidate