*Faults unsigned election result, rules aspirant failed to prove victory in Ekiti primary
Justice Inyang Ekwo of the Federal High Court sitting in Abuja has dismissed a suit filed by an All Progressives Congress (APC) aspirant, Ayodele Oluwatemi Abe, challenging the outcome of the party’s primary election for Ekiti South Federal Constituency I, ruling that he failed to provide credible evidence to establish his alleged victory.
Delivering judgment on Tuesday, Justice Ekwo held that although Abe had the legal right to challenge alleged irregularities in the conduct of the primary, he failed to prove that he actually won the election.
Abe had claimed that he polled 9,953 votes to defeat other aspirants in the primary conducted on May 16, 2026. He accused the APC of refusing to recognise him as its duly nominated candidate for the 2027 House of Representatives election.
He consequently asked the court to declare him the winner of the primary and compel the party to forward his name to the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) as its candidate for the constituency.
He also sought orders restraining Toyin Okoro, the first defendant, from presenting himself as the party’s validly nominated candidate, as well as preventing the APC and INEC from recognising his candidature.
However, Justice Ekwo rejected the APC’s argument that the dispute concerned the internal affairs of the party and was therefore not justiciable.
Relying on Section 88(2) of the Electoral Act, 2026, the judge held that an aspirant who alleges non-compliance with the provisions of the Act or a political party’s guidelines in the selection or nomination of candidates has the right to seek redress before the Federal High Court.
According to the judge, the use of the word “notwithstanding” in the provision gives the statutory right priority over arguments bordering on the internal affairs of political parties.
He consequently held that Abe had the legal standing, or locus standi, to institute the action, dismissing the objection raised by the second defendant.
Despite this finding, the court held that the plaintiff failed to establish his alleged victory with credible evidence.
Abe had tendered a document titled “All Progressives Congress, Ekiti South Federal Constituency 1 Primary Election 2026”, which he claimed contained the results collated by his agents.
The document, admitted as Exhibit G, showed that Abe scored 9,953 votes, while Okoro polled 2,841 votes. Other aspirants, Adeniyi Rufus Ojuawo, Olajuyin Olasunkanmi and Alabi Idowu, were credited with 2,121, 488 and 106 votes respectively.
But Justice Ekwo held that the document was unsigned and therefore lacked probative value.
Citing several judicial authorities, including Tumbido v. INEC (2023), the judge stressed that an unsigned document was worthless in law and could not be relied upon to establish a disputed fact.
The court also rejected Exhibit H, an application dated May 26, 2026, through which Abe requested certified true copies of the primary election result sheets and other relevant documents from INEC.
The judge held that the application only established that the plaintiff had attempted to obtain the documents but did not prove the actual outcome of the election.
Similarly, a flash drive tendered by the plaintiff and played in open court, alongside its transcription, failed to establish that he won the primary.
According to the judge, the evidence merely showed that Abe participated in the exercise as an aspirant.
Justice Ekwo maintained that the appropriate evidence of the outcome of a party primary was the result sheet duly signed by persons authorised by the political party, unless an inherent defect in the document was established through credible evidence.
The court also rejected a Premium Times online report tendered by the plaintiff, holding that it failed to satisfy the requirements of Section 84 of the Evidence Act, 2011, governing the admissibility of electronic evidence.
Relying on the Supreme Court decision in Multichoice (Nig.) Ltd. v. M.C.S.N. Ltd. Gte. (2020), the judge held that electronic evidence must meet the statutory conditions for admissibility, either through oral evidence or an appropriate certificate of compliance.
He consequently ruled that the online publication was inadmissible and could not be accorded any probative value.
The judge further reiterated that a plaintiff must succeed on the strength of his own case and not on the perceived weakness of the defence.
Citing Oyinloye v. Esinkin (1999) and Adekunle v. Aremu (1998), among other authorities, he emphasised that the burden of proof rests on the party making the claim.
In a strong admonition at the beginning of the judgment, Justice Ekwo also criticised the parties for what he described as avoidable verbosity and excessive repetition in their court processes.
He observed that cases were won or lost on credible evidence rather than lengthy addresses by counsel, stressing that legal arguments could not substitute for proof.
The judge consequently held that Abe failed to discharge the burden of proof required by law and dismissed the suit for lacking in merit.