News
For Arrogance, Tribunal Fines Multichoice N150m, Orders One-Month Free Service To DSTV, GOTV Subscribers
By Kayode Sanni-Arewa
The Competition and Consumer Protection Tribunal has fined prominent Pay-TV operator, Multichoice Nigeria, N150 million administrative charges for challenging the jurisdiction of a court sitting in Abuja that recently restrained it from increasing the prices of its DStv and GOtv packages.
The verdict delivered by three of the panel led by Thomas Okosu on Friday also ordered Multichoice to give Nigerians a one-month free subscription on DSTV and GOTV.
The Tribunal had restrained MultiChoice from increasing its subscription rates pending the hearing and determination of a motion on notice filed by Barrister Festus Onifade.
Onifade, who sued Multi-Choice Nigeria Ltd, and the Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC), accused Pay TV of unjustly increasing subscription fees without one-month notice to customers and leveraging it to seek interim orders against Pay TV.
A three-member tribunal chaired by Saratu Shafii had ruled in favour of Onifade by restraining Multichoice in the interim, in the suit marked CCPT/OP/2/2024, restraining the pay TV from going ahead with the impending price increase scheduled to take effect from 1st May 2024 pending the hearing and determination of the Motion on Notice.
But Multichoice’s lawyer, Moyosore .J. Onibanjo (SAN) filed a preliminary objection, urging the court to decline jurisdiction on the suit filed by Festus Onifade and strike it out because such a price dispute case had been decided before in favour of his client.
Onibanjo also tendered and adopted the previous judgement of the tribunal in suit no CCPT/OP/1/2022(Exhibit A), alongside his application, saying when a court has determined an issue between the same parties on the same subject matter before, that matter cannot be re-litigated again by any tribunal or court.
He averred that the power to regulate prices was vested in the president of Nigeria, adding that the Tribunal was not the forum where the claimant could come to seek to regulate the prices and services offered by Multichoice.
On his part, Onifade argued that the issue he placed before the court was whether Multichoice Nigeria gave adequate notice in respect of the May 1, 2024 price TV subscription increase, and not price regulation or increase.
“It is our submission that the 8-day notice issued by Multichoice Nigeria is insufficient in law. A monthly subscriber should be given at least a month.
“Dismiss this application (by Multichoice )for being a waste of time of the court,” Onifade prayed.
Onifade also asked the Tribunal to direct Multi-choice Nigeria Limited to pay the sum of N1,000,000,000.00 (One Billion Naira only) or any amount the Tribunal may deem fit or appropriate in this circumstance for “deliberately disobeying, contravening, and failure to comply with the Interim Order of this Honourable Tribunal granted on the 29th April 2024.”
Counsel for the FCCPC, Nikiomari Abeke, told the CCPT that he was not opposing the application of Multichoice Nigeria but would abide by the direction of the tribunal regarding all the processes before it.
On Friday, the three-man panel chaired by Justice Thomas Okosu held that Section 39(2) of the FCCPC Act states that the tribunal shall have jurisdiction throughout the federation and on all commercial activities aimed at making a profit.
“The jurisdiction of this tribunal extends to all business activities within Nigeria,” Okosu said.
He said he looked at relevant provisions cited by parties and did not find where an aggrieved consumer who sought to enforce his rights was required to file a complaint to the President of Nigeria or the Price Control Board.
The judge also observed that the claimant wrote letters to the FCCPC before filing his case.
“I have come to the conclusion that this tribunal has the jurisdiction to preside over consumer rights as in the instant case and I resolve this issue against Multichoice,” the judge said.
Besides, the tribunal held that the claimant’s instant suit was not questioning the Multichoice price hike as claimed by Onibanjo but the illegality of his client’s 8-days notice to the customers.
The Tribunal noted that Multichoice had already disobeyed its interim orders, adding that its action of hiking DSTV and GOTV prices was condemnable and must not be condoned by the Tribunal.
The tribunal dismissed Multichoice’s preliminary objection for disobeying its interim orders.
Subsequently, the Tribunal imposed an administrative penalty on Multichoice for failing to comply with an order of the tribunal
“The first defendant is hereby mandated to pay N150 million penalty.
“Multichoice is hereby ordered to give Nigerians one month free subscription.”
Recall that Multichoice announced new price adjustments on DStv and GOtv packages on Wednesday, April 24, 2024.
The email message to subscribers read, “On Wednesday, 1 May 2024 we will adjust our prices across all our packages on OStv and GOtv. We understand the impact this change may have on you – our valued customer, but the rise in the cost of business operations, has led us to make this difficult decision. It remains our mission to provide the best entertainment and viewing experience to you and are committed to continue to deliver high-quality content and unparalleled service.”
The development had resulted in a 25% to 26% increase across Multichoice packages.
But amid the subsisting ruling, the popular Pay TV provider, proceeded with the upward adjustment of its prices for DStv and GOtv subscribers.
On the part of the commission, it said it would review the reasons identified by Multichoice, noting that the agency could involve regulatory bodies such as the National Broadcasting Commission (NBC).
News
ECHOES from one-day national dialogue on home grown Parliamentary System in Nigeria(Photos)
… Nigerians are not inherently corrupt we can design our own system -Chinda
…I ‘m a refugee in my own country -Ita-Giwa
… let’s restructure our presidential system- Ex-Gov of Kano, Shekarau
…we made a fatal error adopting presidential system -Prof Abdullahi
By Emmanuel Agaji
Echoes from the one-day national dialogue on home grown Parliamentary System has continued reverberate one week after it was held in Abuja to drum support for it.
The Dialogue to ensure Nigerians savour its own home grown Parliamentary System entered a different level last Monday as dignitaries from all walks of life espoused different views on the subject matter at the Shehu Yar’Dua International Conference Centre, Abuja.
Panelist of men of substance from egg heads to former governors, clergymen , former speaker, serving lawmakers all gathered to find a common solution to governance shift that would adopt Nigeria’s peculiarities and take Nigerians to the promised land.
Ango Abdullahi:
Firing from all cylinders last Monday was a former varsity Vice Chancellor, Professor Ango Abdullahi who declared that Nigeria was too much in a hurry to dump the Parliamentary System after practicing it for just five years.
He noted that the then military made it clear that the constituent assembly was told Parliamentary system was a no go area.
The professor said it was a mistake to have gone ahead to adopt the US presidential system which “we’re greatly regretting now and a parliamentary system should be adopted to ease cost of governance.
Senator Shekarau:
Former governor of Kano State and leader of Northern Democrats, Senator Ibrahim Shekarau called for a structural adjustment of the presidential system we practice now to reduce cost of governance.
Senator Ita l-Giwa
In her short message, Senator Florence Ita-Giwa without minciing words declared that Nigeria is not moving ahead because of the bogus system “I am a refugee in my country today after the Bakassi issue and nobody is rehabilitating me.
Kingsley Chinda:
A co-convener and HoR Minority Caucus leader Kingsley Chinda as one of panelists gave a vivid breakdown on the way forward as the last panelist to speak.
“I think that restates the cliche by Alexander Pope referred to by His Excellency that for every form of government they must contend for whatever is best administered.
“But I think it’s not just those who administer the system, you must also have a system that is administrable in your own circumstances.
“And that is why today if you ask, some persons might even say that Nigerians are inherently corrupt but that is not the case.
He stressed further: “When we started we were not like this, so you ask the question where did we get it wrong?
“The only thing that we have seen is that the system we imported, the laws we have so much loopholes and it makes it comfortable for us public office holders to do things that we get away with easily.
“The former speaker talked about the issue of impeachment, removing a councillor under our present law is almost an impossibility and so the councillor knows, I’m not talking about members of the National Assembly, I’m not talking about the executive, the councillor at the ward level because you have to get majority signatures of voters and that will be confirmed by INEC, how do you do that? When even the voters register had more than 50% ghost names, so where are you going to get the 50% genuine persons and their signatures confirmed?
“So this system has inherent loopholes that will allow those who are administering it to go scotfree and we need to tighten it.
“Anothet reason why we say so is that the same Nigerian who takes pride in beating the traffic light, who takes pride with even the NEPA at home you would want to do a bypass, send that same person to Ghana, I’m not talking about the United States, send him to Ghana and there is a queue somewhere, he will line up quietly because he knows that the system is not the same thing he had at home.
” So some people talk about mindset change, yes you might think about mindset change but to me the person sitting behind, the children behind are the people that require a mindset change because we already know that what we are doing is wrong and when we go to a clime where they have a better and stronger system we behave ourselves, so what mind are you going to change?
“We need to change the system, we need to begin to provide stronger penalty for those who commit crime.
“I remembered once either in the 8th or 7th Assembly we proposed a bill for death penalty for public office holders that steal public funds, it did not see the light of day.
” I think that we should begin to take extreme measures that will discourage public office holders from doing the things that they do.
“And the current presidential system we practice is one that allows a lot of leverage, there are so many things that are morally wrong but legally they are right under our laws and so it becomes difficult to hold anybody culpable even where people criticise over such actions.
“And for us to move on, we must begin to look at our own peculiar attitudes and couch laws that will take care of them, that is the homegrown.
“Homegrown is not that we look at our culture, tradition and all that, no. What are Nigerians likely to do if you give them this opportunity.
“Let me use discretion, if you bring a public office holder in Europe and bring a Nigerian public office holder and ask them to exercise discretion on an issue, I’m sure that you will agree that the Nigerian public office holder will be looking at religion, tribe whilst taking that matter.
News
“Be dedicated to Nigerians as God is watching you”-Onaiyekan cautions Tinubu
The Emeritus Archbishop of Abuja, Cardinal John Onaiyekan, says though more Nigerians voted against President Bola Tinubu in the 2023 election, he has a duty to serve all Nigerians.
According to him, Tinubu, the then-candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC), should switch from campaign mode to governance mode and serve every part of the country equally.
The respected cleric was a guest on the Sunday edition of Inside Sources with Laolu Akande, a socio-political programme on Channels Television.
Cardinal Onaiyekan warned Tinubu against running a polarised government where his political cronies are rewarded with appointments and the parts of the country where he got hefty votes are also rewarded with projects.
He said, “There are Nigerians who did not vote for APC. Granted that APC got the highest number of votes and that is why they have the right to rule us. But they also forget that there are millions of Nigerians who did not (vote for the APC).
“Whatever the rules say, the reality is that more people vote against Mr President than those who voted for him.
“Even if you are a minority government, which is what I call what we have now, you still have a duty to serve the people and to do all you can to give everybody what is their right, and to rule well.”
‘God Is Watching’
Cardinal Onaiyekan urged the President to do his best to move the nation forward as he would give account of his stewardship to God.
“Mr President, it’s about time you switched from campaign mode to governance mode. Elections are over. Campaigns are over. You now have to govern and govern the whole of Nigeria and every Nigerian.
Advertisement
“And therefore, the whole system whereby high political offices are given as a reward for those who were political activists, I don’t believe that that is the best way to move the nation forward.
“I would say, now that you (Tinubu) have been declared the President of Nigeria, sit down comfortably on that chair. As a religious leader, I would say God has allowed you on that chair. If God puts you there, you must then know that he is watching you and that He will be asking you what you did on that chair,” he said
News
Wema Bank Appoints New Deputy Managing Director and Executive Director
Wema Bank, Nigeria’s innovative leader in banking and pioneer of Africa’s first fully digital bank, ALAT, is pleased to announce the appointment of a new Deputy Managing Director and an Executive Director. These strategic appointments, approved by the Board, come as part of the bank’s commitment to ensuring strong leadership succession. The new roles will take effect on December 1, 2024, following the retirement of Mr. Oluwole Akinleye, the current Deputy Managing Director.
Mr. Akinleye, whose retirement will be effective November 30, 2024, has been a vital pillar of Wema Bank’s growth and transformation. Over the past decade, he has demonstrated exemplary leadership across various capacities, including overseeing the Southwest Business, Corporate Banking Division, Customer Experience Management, and Corporate Sustainability. His tenure has been marked by significant contributions to the bank’s strategic objectives and market positioning.
In expressing gratitude for his service, the Board of Directors and management of the Bank disclosed that Mr. Akinleye’s dedication and strategic foresight have been instrumental to Wema Bank’s transformation journey. He is deeply appreciated for his invaluable contributions and they wish him the very best in his future endeavors.
As part of its robust succession planning, Wema Bank has appointed Mr. Oluwole Ajimisinmi as Deputy Managing Director. Mr. Ajimisinmi, who joined Wema Bank in 2009 as Company Secretary/Legal Adviser, was appointed as an Executive Director in 2020. With years of experience in corporate governance, strategic leadership, and banking, he is well-positioned to steer the bank towards its next phase of growth and innovation.
The bank has also named Mr. Olukayode Bakare as Executive Director, effective the same date. A seasoned finance and treasury expert with years of industry experience, Mr. Bakare has been a key driver of Wema Bank’s Treasury, Wholesale Funding, and Global Trade Business. His extensive expertise and leadership will further bolster the bank’s commitment to delivering innovative financial solutions.
Commenting on these appointments, the Board of Directors and management of the Bank said these appointments underscore Wema Bank’s commitment to building a future-ready leadership team. According to the Bank, Mr. Ajimisinmi and Mr. Bakare bring a wealth of expertise, passion, and a clear vision to their new roles. The Bank is confident that their leadership will propel Wema Bank to new heights, ensuring sustained innovation and value creation for its stakeholders.
Wema Bank remains committed to its mission of delivering cutting-edge banking solutions through technology and innovation. With these leadership changes, the Bank is poised to maintain its position as a trailblazer in Nigeria’s financial services sector.
-
News23 hours ago
BREAKING: INEC declares Aiyedatiwa of APC winner of Ondo guber election
-
News23 hours ago
VIDEO: God’s kingdom is your birthright it’s not negotiable -Bishop Elim(Part 1)
-
News23 hours ago
Victor Osimhen regrets says “I Sent €5000 to childhood friend and he failed to appreciate
-
News23 hours ago
BREAKING: APC Picks All 20 Chairmanship, 236 Councillorship Seats In Ogun LG Polls
-
News24 hours ago
Community Snubs Council Chairman’s Flood Relief Materials, Declares ‘We’re Not Hungry’
-
News8 hours ago
Police arrest 2 suspected cultists with arms in Edo
-
News8 hours ago
‘I’ll never accept any female’s award again’ – Bobrisky blames Eniola Ajao for his problems
-
News8 hours ago
Ondo Guber: Tinubu Tells PDP, Others; Go To Court If Dissatisfied